Bankruptcy remote is not bankruptcy proof. What a 2025 ruling means for your SPE structures

If you sponsor real estate deals financed through a special purpose entity, you have signed loan documents that put an independent manager or a blocking member between your entity and the bankruptcy court. A January 2025 decision, In re 301 W North Avenue, LLC, states when that consent requirement holds and when a court will void it. The stakes run both ways for a sponsor. In distress, that provision decides whether your entity can file at all. Understanding the line protects you when you negotiate the documents and when you later need options.
What a blocker is
A blocker is a person or entity given the power to stop the SPE from filing for bankruptcy. The entity’s governing documents state that no voluntary bankruptcy petition can be filed without that party’s consent. Because the party can withhold consent and thereby block the filing, it functions as a veto.
The blocker goes by different names depending on the structure. Common versions are an independent director, an independent manager, a special member, or a golden share held by a designated party. The label varies, but the function is the same. The entity cannot file without the blocker’s approval.
Lenders require a blocker so that a borrower in distress cannot unilaterally put the collateral into bankruptcy. A bankruptcy filing triggers an automatic stay that halts foreclosure, and it opens the door to a court restructuring the debt over the lender’s objection. The blocker gives the lender a role in that decision. As the rest of this article explains, whether the veto holds up depends on the duties the blocker owes.
When you will encounter a blocker
Blocker structures are not limited to large institutional deals. They are close to universal in CMBS and other securitized loans, and they are standard in most balance sheet loans from institutional lenders across a wide range of loan sizes, because the rating agency and bankruptcy remoteness criteria that drive them get applied well down into the middle market. You are less likely to see a full independent manager structure in genuinely small deals from a community bank, a credit union, or a private or bridge lender. Those lenders often rely on a simpler SPE covenant, a recourse guaranty, or a springing carve out guaranty instead. The presence of a blocker depends more on the type of lender and whether the loan is headed for securitization than on deal size alone. If your loan is securitized or comes from an institutional lender, you should expect one.
The 301 W North Avenue background, in detail
The facts show how these structures are built and how they fail. They are worth walking through because your own deal likely followed the same template.
The borrower, 301 W North Avenue, LLC, was a Delaware limited liability company. Its only real asset was a mixed use development in Chicago known as the North Park Pointe Apartments. The building had seven stories and a partial eighth level, and it held 69 residential units and roughly 4,268 square feet of retail space.
On September 23, 2020, the lender made a loan to the borrower in the original principal amount of $26 million, secured by the property. Before closing, the lender’s term sheet required the borrower to be a bankruptcy remote entity and to have one acceptable independent director. To fill that role, on September 3, 2020, the borrower signed a staffing agreement with a corporate services company that supplies independent managers. That company designated an individual who, at the time of the litigation, served as an independent director or manager for more than 500 entities.
The governing documents did the work. The loan agreement barred the borrower from filing a bankruptcy petition without the unanimous written consent of all members plus the consent of the independent director. It required the organizational documents to keep at least one independent director in place at all times, and it required advance written notice to the lender before that director could be removed or replaced. The LLC agreement, entered at about the same time, designated the independent manager and imposed on her a fiduciary duty of loyalty and care similar to that of a Delaware corporate director. It also directed her to consider the interests of the members and the company, including the company’s creditors. That last point turned out to be decisive.
The loan matured on October 1, 2023. The borrower did not pay, which was an event of default. On December 15, 2023, the lender started a foreclosure action. The day before a hearing in that action, on February 27, 2024, the borrower filed for Chapter 11.
Here is where the structure was tested. The borrower filed without consulting the independent manager. The consent document authorizing the filing did not even contain a signature block for her. At the borrower’s creditors meeting on March 27, 2024, the principal who signed the petition testified that he was not aware of anyone who held consent rights and did not recognize the independent manager’s name. The independent manager testified that no one consulted her before the filing and that she first learned of the bankruptcy in late April 2024, through a subpoena from the lender’s counsel. She then signed a resignation notice on April 30, 2024, but backdated it to August 31, 2022, the last date the staffing company had been paid.
The lender moved to dismiss for lack of corporate authority. On January 6, 2025, the court granted the motion. It made two separate rulings, and both matter to you.
First, on authority, the court found that the independent manager’s consent was required and was never obtained. It rejected the borrower’s attempts to work around that fact. The manager had not resigned before the filing, because her signed resignation came two months after it. Her conduct was neither acquiescence nor ratification. Resigning promptly after learning of the filing, the court said, was consistent with rejecting the filing, not approving it. Because consent was required and absent, the borrower lacked authority to file.
Second, on enforceability, the court held that the LLC agreement did not improperly restrict the borrower’s right to file. This is the ruling that gives the case its significance. Because the agreement preserved the manager’s fiduciary duties and extended them to the company and its creditors, the consent requirement was valid rather than an impermissible waiver of the right to file. The case was dismissed. The court declined to bar the borrower from refiling, reasoning that a properly appointed independent manager should be free to decide whether to consent to a new filing.
The line courts actually draw
For roughly ten years, bankruptcy courts voided blocking provisions on one recurring ground. The blocking party owed no fiduciary duty to the company. In In re Intervention Energy Holdings, LLC, a golden share held by a creditor was struck down because the holder’s real relationship was that of a lender, and it owed a duty to no one but itself. In In re Lake Michigan Beach Pottawattamie Resort LLC and in In re Lexington Hospitality Group, LLC, a manager instructed to consider only the lender’s interests, with duties to the company stripped away, was voided on the same basis. The court in Lexington stated the principle directly. An independent decision maker cannot exist only to vote no. It must carry normal fiduciary duties. The common thread across every voided provision was the absence of duties running to the company and its creditors.
301 W North Avenue clarifies the test. The court held that these provisions are not presumptively void. A structure that respects the manager’s fiduciary duties and complies with state law is enforceable. A structure that effectively nullifies the right to file is not. The court focused the question on whether the entity’s right to file is restricted, not on whether the manager owes duties to the members. A lender can restrict or even eliminate duties to members as long as duties to the company and its creditors survive.
The one circuit decision that goes the other way
You should know the contrary authority. The Fifth Circuit, in In re Franchise Services of North America, Inc., held that a bona fide equity holder can vote against a petition even without owing a fiduciary duty. In that case, an investment bank’s subsidiary held nearly half of the company’s equity as preferred stock and used its charter based consent right to block a bankruptcy filing. The court treated the authority to file as a matter of state corporate law. It rejected the argument that a veto is void without a matching fiduciary duty, and it distinguished the situation from one in which a creditor contracts for a veto or the equity stake is a mere ruse. This is the only circuit level ruling on point. Later courts have distinguished it, and it is not binding outside the Fifth Circuit. If your entity is organized or would file in the Fifth Circuit, the analysis may differ. Elsewhere you should not count on it.
What this means when you negotiate and when you file
Delaware law supplies the tools that shape these provisions. The LLC Act gives maximum effect to freedom of contract. It permits an agreement to expand, restrict, or eliminate fiduciary duties, and it permits duties to be directed toward the company and its creditors. Even a full waiver leaves the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing intact as a backstop that the manager cannot contract around.
Several points deserve your attention as a sponsor.
First, read the interests clause closely before you sign. A provision that directs the independent manager to the interests of the SPE, including its creditors, is the enforceable formulation. A provision that directs the manager to consider only the lender’s interests is the kind courts have voided. Which one you accept affects whether the entity can file at all if the need arises.
Second, understand who your independent manager actually serves. These managers are usually supplied by a service that places the same individual across hundreds of entities, and the position exists as a condition of the loan. That does not make the provision unenforceable, but it tells you the consent is not a formality. If your entity reaches distress, the manager owes duties to the company and its creditors and will exercise independent judgment.
Third, know what an unauthorized filing costs you. If a valid consent provision exists and you file without the required consent, the petition is unauthorized and subject to dismissal for lack of corporate authority. That is lost time, lost fees, and lost leverage at the worst possible moment. Get the consent first.
Fourth, know the opposite outcome. If the blocking provision is void, the entity’s remaining governance provisions may supply the authority to file. A poorly drafted lender veto can leave you with more freedom than the lender intended.
One caution applies across the board. No Delaware Supreme Court or Third Circuit decision has resolved whether a duty stripped blocker is enforceable. The law is not fully settled. When you negotiate these documents, have counsel model both scenarios, meaning the provision holds and the provision falls, so you know your position before distress rather than after.
Sources
- In re 301 W North Avenue, LLC, 666 B.R. 583 (Bankr. N.D. Ill. 2025). Opinion posted by the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Illinois: https://www.ilnb.uscourts.gov/content/re-301-w-north-avenue-llc
- In re Franchise Services of North America, Inc., 891 F.3d 198 (5th Cir. 2018). Full opinion on CourtListener: https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4500305/franchise-servs-of-n-am-inc-v-us-tr-in-re-franchise-servs-of-n/
About Murphy PC
Murphy PC is a Boston-based law firm focusing on real estate and business transactions. The firm counsels developers, sponsors, owners, investors, lenders, tenants, nonprofits, and partnerships in joint ventures, project development, acquisitions and dispositions, financing, leasing, construction, and title insurance across all property types.