Murphy PC

One Missing Date Voided an LLC Buyout and Turned an Exit into a Lawsuit

If you own a business through an LLC with partners, your exit plan lives in one document, the operating agreement. A recent Massachusetts court decision shows what happens when you skip a single step in it. The buyout fell apart, and every member walked away worse off.

The case is Mendes v. Gill, No. 2282CV00135 (Mass. Super. Ct., Norfolk Cty., Sept. 14, 2026) (Gant, J.). It applied Delaware law to a Delaware LLC. It’s a trial court ruling, so it doesn’t bind other courts and may be appealed. But the clauses at issue appear in many operating agreements, possibly yours.

A buyout both sides signed still failed

Three partners owned JKS Technologies, an IT services company, in equal thirds. In October 2020, Korey Mendes offered to sell his stake to the other two for the balance of his capital account. They accepted in writing within the 30 day offer period.

There was one problem. The agreement said the acceptance shall fix a closing date between 10 and 90 days out. Neither acceptance named a date.

Another clause said any transfer made without “strict compliance” is null and void. The court enforced it as written. The parties later agreed on $6,000 monthly payments, and three payments went out. None of that saved the deal. Under Delaware law, a transfer voided by that kind of language can’t be fixed by later conduct.

The court also held the remaining members breached the agreement by skipping the closing date. Worse, because the offer was never properly accepted, the agreement called for the company to be dissolved. Mendes may now seek damages tied to that missed dissolution.

A void buyout means the seller never left

Here’s the twist.  Because the sale never happened, Mendes stayed a member. And members owe the company a duty of loyalty.

While he thought he was on his way out, Mendes had started a competing firm, UplinkIT. He moved JKS customers to it, and every customer he solicited followed. By March 2026, UplinkIT had billed former JKS clients more than $1.26 million.

Mendes pointed to a clause letting members run competing businesses. The court said that wasn’t enough. Delaware lets you waive the corporate opportunity doctrine (the rule that a fiduciary can’t take business the company could pursue itself), but only in plain, unambiguous words. Permission to compete is not the same as permission to take the company’s own customers. The court found Mendes liable for breach of fiduciary duty.

The other members don’t escape either. Mendes’s claim that they squeezed him out, including by withholding tax distributions while he owed tax on his share of profits, is headed to trial.

Three fixes to make now

You can avoid this outcome with a few deliberate steps. The following are the ones that matter most.

  • Follow the transfer procedure exactly, and put the closing date in the acceptance itself.
  • Know what your agreement says happens if a transfer fails. Here, it was automatic dissolution, which no one seemed to want.
  • If members may pursue opportunities the company could take, say so expressly. If they may not, say that too.

Until closing, a departing member should act like a member. Remaining members shouldn’t treat that person as gone, for example by dropping them from tax returns early, as happened here.

What this means for commercial real estate

A great deal of commercial real estate is held in LLCs, often Delaware LLCs with two or three sponsors or a sponsor and an equity partner. Those agreements are full of buy and sell rights, rights of first offer, and outside activities clauses. This decision touches all of them.

For example, two partners own a retail center through an LLC. One partner wants out and the other accepts, but the acceptance skips a required step. The departing partner then signs a tenant from the center to a competing project he’s developing down the street. Under this court’s reasoning, the sale may be void, and he may owe the venture for the tenant he took. A clause saying members may own other properties may not protect him unless it expressly waives opportunities the venture could pursue.

Owners, sponsors, and investors should check their buy and sell mechanics and outside activities clauses before a partner leaves. Lenders and buyers doing diligence should confirm that every past transfer of membership interests actually complied with the agreement, because a void transfer can leave the cap table different from what the records show.

Your operating agreement means exactly what it says, so read it before you need it, and have counsel review the exit and competition clauses now.

About Murphy PC

Murphy PC is a Boston-based law firm focusing on real estate and business transactions. The firm counsels developers, sponsors, owners, investors, lenders, tenants, nonprofits, and partnerships in joint ventures, project development, acquisitions and dispositions, financing, leasing, construction, and title insurance across all property types.

Related Posts