How a Delaware Operating Agreement Can Erase the Duty Your Co-owner Owes You
If you own an interest in an LLC, you probably assume your co-owners owe you loyalty and care. You assume they can’t lawfully act against your interest, take an opportunity that belonged to the company, or run the entity for their own benefit. For a Delaware LLC, that assumption is only as good as your operating agreement. A single clause can eliminate those duties almost entirely, and a 2024 decision from the District of Massachusetts shows a court enforcing exactly that result.
The case is Employers Mutual Casualty Co. v. Homeland Power & Utility LLC, 2024 WL 3952707 (D. Mass. Aug. 27, 2024). The fiduciary-duty holding is the part worth your attention.
The dispute
Cousins Michael and Jonathan Carpenter co-founded an electrical contractor, Homeland Power. Ownership ran through a holding company, Homeland Holding, in which Michael held 51 percent and Jonathan 49 percent. The entity was manager-managed, with Jonathan initially the sole manager. When Homeland Power became insolvent, Jonathan was removed as manager and the company was liquidated.
The surety, EMC, had issued payment and performance bonds backed by a general indemnity agreement that Michael and Jonathan each signed individually, accepting joint and several liability. After the default, EMC’s net loss ran to roughly $2.27 million. EMC settled confidentially with Michael, then pursued Jonathan for the full amount, which joint and several liability let it do. Jonathan responded with crossclaims against Michael for breach of fiduciary duty and for tortious conduct compelling another to defend.
Those crossclaims are the part to watch. Jonathan lost them because of what the operating agreement said, nothing more.
Why Delaware law governed, and why that mattered
The Homeland Holding operating agreement contained a Delaware governing-law clause. The court applied it without independent choice-of-law analysis, because the parties agreed Delaware law controlled the internal-governance dispute. That follows the internal affairs doctrine, under which the law of the state where the LLC was formed governs the relationships among members, managers, and the entity.
That choice of law changed the outcome. Delaware’s LLC Act, 6 Del. C. § 18-1101(c), permits an operating agreement to expand, restrict, or eliminate fiduciary duties. It imposes one real limit. The elimination must be plain and unambiguous, and the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing can never be waived. Many states are less permissive. So the governing-law clause matters. It picks the law that decides whether a loyalty claim can be brought at all.
How the drafting eliminated the duties
The agreement didn’t announce that no member owes any fiduciary duty. It did something subtler and just as effective. Article 6.15 provided that each member was “subject only to the fiduciary duties set forth in this Agreement.” The agreement then set forth none. By pointing all duties to the document and then listing none, the drafters wiped out members’ fiduciary duties almost completely. The one duty that survived was the implied covenant, which can’t be waived. The court read this as satisfying Delaware’s plain-and-unambiguous standard.
Jonathan raised the argument any careful reader would. A separate “Effect of LLC Act” provision, Article 18.8, appeared to preserve the statutory and common-law duties the Act would otherwise supply. The court rejected it on ordinary contract-interpretation grounds. That clause, by its own terms, yielded to the rest of the agreement in any conflict. The specific waiver in Article 6.15 governed over the general savings clause. A boilerplate “the Act applies except as modified herein” provision does not resurrect duties the agreement deliberately displaced.
With no fiduciary duty owed, the breach claim failed as a matter of law. The tortious-conduct claim failed with it, because the only duty it rested on was the eliminated fiduciary duty. No predicate duty, no tort.
What this means for your own deals
The value here isn’t the surety mechanics. It’s a clean illustration of how much a Delaware operating agreement can rearrange the default relationship among owners. Carry these points into your next negotiation.
Duty elimination is usually structural, not headlined. Look past any section titled “fiduciary duties.” The operative move reads as innocuous and functions as a near-total waiver. It says members are subject only to the duties set forth in the agreement, and then the agreement says nothing. If you are the minority or non-managing member, this is the clause that decides whether you have a remedy when things go wrong.
The governing-law clause is a substantive term, not a formality. Delaware permits elimination that several other states restrict or prohibit. Negotiate it the way you negotiate an economic term, and understand what the chosen state’s law allows before you sign.
General savings clauses will not save you. An “Effect of the Act” catch-all that seems to preserve statutory duties usually subordinates itself to the agreement’s specific terms. Don’t rely on it to backstop protections the tailored provisions removed. If you want a duty preserved, state it affirmatively and specifically.
Elimination can be the right call when it’s deliberate. Waiving duties gives owners latitude to pursue competing ventures and to act without the constant exposure that broad loyalty obligations create. The problem in these disputes is rarely that the clause exists. It’s that a party agreed to it without pricing in the loss of recourse. If duties are being waived, the members losing them should get something in return. Think enhanced information rights, approval thresholds, buy-sell protections, or an express carve-out for specified conduct.
The implied covenant is your last protection. Even a full waiver leaves the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing intact under Delaware law. It is narrow and won’t substitute for a fiduciary claim, but no operating agreement can contract it away. Treat it as a backstop, not a strategy.
Bottom line
In a Delaware LLC, the operating agreement defines what your co-owners owe you. Background law does not. A short, easily overlooked clause can eliminate loyalty and care almost completely, and courts will enforce it when the drafting is clear. Before you sign or amend, read the fiduciary-duty and governing-law provisions together, and make sure the duties you’re keeping or giving up are the ones you meant to.
About Murphy PC
Murphy PC is a Boston-based law firm focusing on real estate and business transactions. The firm counsels developers, sponsors, owners, investors, lenders, tenants, nonprofits, and partnerships in joint ventures, project development, acquisitions and dispositions, financing, leasing, construction, and title insurance across all property types.